Quiz: Can You Guess Which Classic Films Got These Bad Reviews?

Quiz: Can You Guess Which Classic Films Got These Bad Reviews?

When a movie first hits screens, no one honestly knows for sure if it’s going to stand the test of time. It doesn’t matter if you’re the most widely read film critic in the world or just another average everyday movie-goer; when you leave the cinema after seeing the latest new film release, all you can really say for sure is whether you liked it or not. And even then, there’s the firm possibility that your feelings on the matter might change with time.

The film industry and its fans tend to place a lot of importance on the critical reception a film receives on opening, particularly today when a ‘fresh’ rating on Rotten Tomatoes is considered a barometer of a film’s success. At the same time, though, there are many who loudly deride film critics, accusing them of trying to somehow control the tastes of others and insisting that the only important opinion is that of the viewer.

However, the important thing to keep in mind is that, when all’s said and done, film critics are simply fans of the medium like any other, and who happen to have a larger platform on which to voice their opinion. Of course they’re not always going to agree on a film’s quality; and of course, they may occasionally voice opinions that don’t hold up years later.

To demonstrate this, we’ve put together some quotes from reviews received on release by movies which are today widely accepted as all-time greats – not that you would think so based on what these critics had to say at the time.

The question is, based on the quotes we’ve provided, can you guess the films which the critics were so dismissive of?

About this quiz

When a movie first hits screens, no one honestly knows for sure if it’s going to stand the test of time. It doesn’t matter if you’re the most widely read film critic in the world or just another average everyday movie-goer; when you leave the cinema after seeing the latest new film release, all you can really say for sure is whether you liked it or not. And even then, there’s the firm possibility that your feelings on the matter might change with time.

The film industry and its fans tend to place a lot of importance on the critical reception a film receives on opening, particularly today when a ‘fresh’ rating on Rotten Tomatoes is considered a barometer of a film’s success. At the same time, though, there are many who loudly deride film critics, accusing them of trying to somehow control the tastes of others and insisting that the only important opinion is that of the viewer.

However, the important thing to keep in mind is that, when all’s said and done, film critics are simply fans of the medium like any other, and who happen to have a larger platform on which to voice their opinion. Of course they’re not always going to agree on a film’s quality; and of course, they may occasionally voice opinions that don’t hold up years later.

To demonstrate this, we’ve put together some quotes from reviews received on release by movies which are today widely accepted as all-time greats – not that you would think so based on what these critics had to say at the time.

The question is, based on the quotes we’ve provided, can you guess the films which the critics were so dismissive of?

About Eighties Kids

Founded in 2016, Eighties Kids started small. Beginning as a blog posting on 80s and 90s life as well as the movies, music and television of the era, Eighties Kids has in a short space of time exploded in scope and ambition. Operating out of Eighties Kids HQ in sunny Ilkley, in the North of England, today a growing team of writers produces original content day in and day out for one of the best new nostalgia sites on the web.

With the site also growing beyond its original remit, the Eighties Kids team now covers not just trivia from the 80s and 90s, but pop culture of all decades that's of interest to children of the 80s, 90s and beyond. From shocking and obscure fact posts on your favourite movies and bands, to quizzes on classic TV shows and film franchises, to picture galleries on celebrities from past and present, Eighties Kids is here to take you down memory lane, test your knowledge of classic pop culture and maybe even occasionally blow your mind.

How to Play

Answering a question, correctly or otherwise, will allow you to progress to the next one; just scroll down and you'll see another question light up and become playable. Keep in mind though: all correct and incorrect answers will be tallied for a final score, which will be revealed to you only once you've answered each and every question in the quiz. Play down the page to the end to find out just how knowledgeable you are in your chosen subject.